|
Please Support our Sponsors | ||||
![]() |
![]() |
Book Review
"Eight-Wheeled Warriors and Grunts"
By Jon Bernstein - Fredericksburg, Virginia USA
Basic Item Information
Title |
Eight-Wheeled Warriors and Grunts: U.S. Marine LAV and Infantry Operations, Spring 2004 |
Author |
Lt. Col. David E. Kelly, USMC (Ret.) |
Publisher |
Casemate Publishers |
ISBN |
9781636244921 |
Media |
Hard Cover Book |
Number of Pages |
304 |
Number/Type of Photos and/or Illustrations |
30 Color Photographs |
Text Language |
English |
Retail Price |
$37.95 USD |
Reviewer |
Jon Bernstein |
Review Date |
March 22, 2025 |
Review Summary*
Review Type |
Full Read |
Recommendation |
Recommended |
Photos
___________________________________________________________________________________________________
Review
Eight Wheeled Warriors and Grunts, by Lt. Col.
David E Kelly, USMC (Ret.) immerses the reader in a sweeping account of
four Marine battalions in 2004 during Operation Iraqi Freedom.
Colonel David E. Kelly volunteered to return to Active Duty as a USMC
History Division field historian in order to deploy with the I Marine
Expeditionary Force and conduct oral history interviews to record
Marines’ experiences immediately after they happened. The
narrative begins with his commentary, arriving in April 2004 and heading
out to the first of four battalions. He quickly switches from his
impressions upon arrival to first person accounts gleaned from his
interviews with the Marines with whom he interacted. His
introduction of each Marine gets into their backgrounds and who they are
as men and Marines, giving significant depth to his “cast of
characters.” Kelly’s commentary throughout serves to tie the
interviews together well.
He builds a keen sense of tension as he
becomes familiar with the situation on the ground and his interviews
with members of the four different Battalions gives the reader a broad
slice of the Marine’s view of the conflict. The 252-page narrative is
broken down into six main chapters around each unit with which he spent
time. Most of the book focuses on the area in and around Ramadi.
Chapter 1 opens with the 2d Light Armored Reconnaissance (LAR) Battalion
in June, covering their counterinsurgent and counter IED operations.
The next three chapters, more than 100 pages, focus on 2d Battalion 7th
Marines moving from Al Asad airbase (Company G) to FOB Hit (Company E)
and ultimately to FOB Korean Village (Company F) through July 2004.
The final two chapters cover the 1st
LAR and 2d Battalion, 4th
Marines. Both, unfortunately feel like afterthoughts rather than
as a continuous part of a larger story. The 2/4 chapter was the
last in chronological order of the interviews Kelly conducted but covers
combat from the previous April. I was hoping for some great images of LAVs in
Iraq in the photo section. There is a nice 8-page photo spread at
the book’s center. Printed on nice glossy paper, the first page
showed four nice shots of LAVs in Ramadi. But the next several pages are
all headshots of individual Marines from all four battalions. While it
does help place a face with those interviewed Marines, as a historian of
technology who is constantly scrambling to find more visual information
on the LAV’s combat history, I was disappointed.
|
Conclusion |
Overall, the book is an engaging read that
captures the intensity of the insurgent war in Iraq. If you’re looking
for a tactical history of the Marine Corps in Iraq during Operation
Iraqi Freedom, this is a great start. However, I would have liked
to see more information on the LAV crews and their experiences in Iraq.
However, the book doesn’t really live up to its title and focuses more
on Grunts than 8-Wheeled Warriors. If you’re looking for an
in-depth record of LAV combat operations, it leaves this reader wanting
more. Recommended. Thanks to Casemate Publishers for the review sample. |
Copyright: Jon Bernstein March 22, 2025 |