|
Please Support our Sponsors | ||||
Book Review of
"Gun Trucks: A Visual History of the U.S. Army's
Vietnam-Era Wheeled Escort Platforms"
By Alan Crawford - Milwaukee, Wisconsin USA
Basic Item Information
Title |
Gun Trucks: A Visual History of the U.S. Army's Vietnam-Era Wheeled Escort Platforms |
Author |
David Doyle |
Publisher |
Ampersand Group, Inc. |
ISBN |
978-0-9861127-3-7 |
Subject |
Vietnam-Era Gun Trucks |
Media |
Soft Cover Book |
Number of Pages |
120 |
Text Language |
English |
Retail Price |
$22.95 USD |
Reviewer |
Alan Crawford |
Review Date |
December 12, 2016 |
Review Summary*
Review Type |
Full Read |
Recommendation |
Highly Recommended |
Photos
___________________________________________________________________________________________________
Detailed Review
The gun truck arguably first made its appearance
during the second world war, when extemporized convoy escort
vehicles - typically armed and armored variations on standard
utility trucks, or sometimes anti-aircraft vehicles - found a role
in defending convoys on high-risk supply routes against ambush. The level of firepower that these vehicles were
able to bring to bear on a target was considerable - a cargo truck
laden with ammo could still mount an appreciable number of heavy
machine guns around its cargo bed, while anti-aircraft mounts were
actually designed to bring a lot of firepower onto a single target
and carry a reasonable supply of ammunition too, so these vehicles
proved highly effective against the attackers that were typically
encountered on these supply routes - more likely to be irregular
infantry, partisans or guerrilla forces than line infantry or enemy
armor.
Gun trucks seem to have
emerged in every asymmetric conflict since that time, the same
lessons re-learned with each new war, but if one war above all has
become associated with the use of gun trucks, it’s been the This period is the focus of David Doyle’s
excellent new reference title published by Ampersand, which nicely
straddles the line between photo reference and history book.
Although the history of gun trucks has tended to be one of
improvisation and field modifications, Doyle’s managed to come up
with a structure for the book that provides comprehensive coverage
and a solid historical background to the combat situation in which
these vehicles evolved - and evolve they did, as the book makes
clear.
While almost anything
with wheels had the potential to be the basis for a gun truck, the
majority of those used in Two other “introductory” chapters cover the other half of the gun truck combination - the guns! The variety of equipment so carried is so extensive that it’s not possible to go into a great deal of depth on most, but Doyle certainly tries to be comprehensive, with photos of everything from the more common handguns through pintle-mounted heavy machine guns, to LAW anti-tank missiles and the devastating XM134 minigun. However, one weapon warrants a chapter all of its own, given the frequency with which it appeared on gun trucks - the M55 quad .50 cal machine gun. Originally developed during WWII as an anti-aircraft weapon and used in towed or vehicle mounted form, if any single weapon is associated with Vietnam-era gun trucks, this is it. Doyle’s coverage includes a nice selection of period photographs, showing the mounts with and without such features as flash suppressors, and also plenty of detail images as well. With the reader now acquainted with the subject
vehicles and the assorted weapons with which they were equipped, we
move onto the real meat of the book. This follows the same
structure as the introductory chapters, covering the gradual
evolution of gun trucks on each of the platforms in turn. So
we see heavily overloaded M35s with makeshift sandbag walls held
between crude sheets of metal give way to more sophisticated field
kits with proper armor plate and weapon mounts, and the emergence of
M35 variants with lowered bed sides to allow their newly mounted
M55s (often with additional armor shields of their own) to rotate
freely. The development of the M54 as a gun track
followed a broadly similar path, but due to the greater payload of
this vehicle, a further “species” of M54 gun truck appeared - those
that mounted the complete hull of an M113 APC in the truck bed.
There were sufficient of these that they warrant a chapter all to
themselves, so we have two full chapters on M54 gun trucks, one on
“conventional” armor bodied vehicles and one on bed-mounted M113
hulls. The subsequent chapters on the M37 and M151 are
rather shorter, since these types weren’t as frequently used, but
they provide plenty of useful material on their subjects.
There’s also a chapter that covers a vehicle not covered in the
introduction, the gun truck of gun trucks, the M328 5-ton bridge
truck. While relatively rare, their combination of heavy-duty
wheels, an extra-long, extra-wide flatbed, and their use being
primarily in engineering units meant that when turned into gun
trucks, they were imposing vehicles. Finally, Doyle devotes a lengthy chapter to a
detailed photo walk around of the last surviving gun truck, the
well-known “Eve of Destruction,” which is preserved in the US Army
Transportation Museum at Fort Eustis. This provides a wealth
of useful images showing close-up detail and interior features that
the period pics often do not capture. I don’t think it’d be an overstatement to state
that there’s barely a redundant image in the entire book, at least
from a modeler’s perspective. The period photos document not
just the many variations in the way vehicles were modified but also
the wide range of highly individualistic markings these vehicles
carried in the field - even if they weren’t bristling with weapons,
you’d never miss a gun truck if it drove past you. The image
quality is generally excellent - absolutely pristine in the case of
the modern photos, with the period photos being generally clean and
fairly crisp, with quite a large proportion looking remarkably good
for their age, and the rest showing only the characteristic color
shift normally associated with film from that era. The
monochrome images are, as you would expect, rather crisper than most
of the color ones. The images included with this review were
chosen pretty much at random from the period photos, to give an idea
of what to expect. As such this book is not only an interesting
historical record of an important class of vehicles, but also
potentially of great use to modelers - at least, those who’re not
daunted by resin conversions and scratch-building. Sadly, the
gun truck is a subject rather poorly served by mainstream
manufacturers - only AFV Club’s M35A1 Gun Truck comes to mind - but
for those comfortable with resin kits, the possibilities expand
considerably, with conversions for the M35 from AFV Club’s parent,
Hobby Fan and Legend, plus several backdate-conversions for the
Italeri M923 series to produce the M54 and several gun trucks on
that platform. While CMK does an armored Mutt conversion for Academy
or Tamiya kits. It’s probably only a matter of time before
somebody does something similar for Roden’s recent M37, so the only
subjects here that seem to really be in the domain of the hardcore
“scratch the whole vehicle” crowd are the M328 gun trucks. Overall, this is an excellent book. As with
all Ampersand books it’s beautifully printed on quality glossy paper
with plenty of quality photographs, and Doyle’s structured the book
in a very reader-friendly way that makes locating the information
you want quick and easy. The quality of writing is equally
high and very informative, setting the context for the development
of the vehicles and documenting their evolution and use. Highly Recommended.
|
Copyright: Alan Crawford - December 12, 2016 |