|
Please Support our Sponsors | ||||
Book Review of
"Italian Soft-Skinned Vehicles of the Second World War: Motorcycles, Cars, Trucks, Artillery Tractors 1935-1945
(Volumes 1 & 2)"
By Glen Phelan - Dublin, Ireland
Basic Item Information
Title |
Italian Soft-Skinned Vehicles of the Second World War: Motorcycles, Cars, Trucks, Artillery Tractors 1935-1945 (Volumes 1 & 2)
|
Author, Editor and/or Illustrator |
Ralph Riccio, Mario Pieri & Daniele Gulielmi |
Publisher |
Helion & Company |
ISBN Number |
Vol 1: 978-1-804513-27-9 Vol 2: 978-1-804514-91-7 |
Subject |
Italian Soft-Skinned Vehicles of the Second World War |
Media |
Softcover Book: Portrait Format (10” x 8”) |
Number of Pages |
Vol 1: 146 Pages Vol 2: 226 Pages |
Number/Type of Photos and/or Illustrations |
Vol 1: Over 330 B&W Photographs & Illustrations with several in colour and six (6) Colour Profiles. Vol
2: Over 480 B&W Photographs
& Illustrations with
several in colour and six (6)
Colour Profiles. |
Text Language |
English |
Retail Price |
$59.95 USD/for Each Volume |
Reviewer |
Glen Phelan |
Review Date |
March 5, 2024 |
Review Summary*
Recommendation |
HIGHLY RECOMMENDED |
Photos
__________________________________________________________________________________________________
Detailed Review
The review copy was provided by
WarWheels sponsor
Casemate Publishers.
I was delighted to receive these books to
review, and I immediately started flipping through the pages, and
getting sucked into the content. On first viewing it’s hard to focus on
any one subject, or its derivatives. There’s just so much in there; And
I mean this as a compliment. The scope of these books is very wide
ranging, and quite impressive. Looking at the list of sources (often
absent from such volumes) and of course the subject matter itself, it’s
evident that a large amount of research and work have gone into the
production of these volumes. There are two volumes, but I will review
and refer to them in most regards, as one work; Which, in fact they are
really. The main subject matter (the vehicle types) is broken down into
eight (8) categories, in addition to the usual list of plates,
acknowledgements, Foreword, glossaries, etc. Categories 1 to 4 are
covered in Volume 1 with 5 to 8 being covered in Volume 2. The authors
are Ralph Riccio (I have read several of his other books, on Irish
subjects, and they are fine works), Mario Pieri and Daniele Guglielmi.
The Colour illustrations are drawn by
David Bocquelet,
and are of a quality and style like that seen in the better monthly
modelling magazines. Before
I go into the detailed breakdown and discussion about the various
content sections, let’s discuss the background of the subject matter,
and how welcome it is in book form; be you an avid historical enthusiast
or modeller, or both. The authors claim this is the first English
language study focussing on soft-skinned vehicles of the Italian Armed
Forces of the 1930s through to the 1940s. This covers a period of
aggressive colonial expansion and the conflicts that elicited
participation. They include (unofficially) the Spanish Civil War and the
cauldron of the Second World War; particularly in North Africa, the
Mediterranean and Italy itself. With that in mind, it is a shame it is
only now such a volume has been published. Most could agree the
subject is much less covered than that of the other major belligerents
in the Second World War. Add to that, while Italian subjects are a rarer
beast, even more so is coverage of their soft-skins (indeed of any
nation). When we
think of dynamic military vehicles, most will picture in their minds-eye
tanks or armoured cars; charging across the fields of France, Steppes of
Russia, or the deserts of North Africa. Rarely is one’s view of the
canvas covered truck ferrying supplies to the front and wounded to the
rear. Or, the tractor hauling artillery into position or immobilised
vehicles from mud, swamp, or water. Yet, these are the vehicles that
were the veins and arteries of war, some even finding a place at the
front line in a combat role. We’ve all heard the sayings of how “an army
marches on its stomach” or when asked what three things a combat
infantryman needed more of, they replied: “ammo, ammo and ammo”. And
dare I quote the statement: “Amateurs talk strategy. Professionals talk
logistics.”? These books cover the very vehicles which carried out the
above essential tasks (and many more) and were the logistical muscle of
the Italian Armed Forces. While the
Italians did have tanks and other AFVs, they were light, and relatively
few. The Italians, influenced by their colonial ambitions and a doctrine
of light mobile forces, concentrated their limited resources on wheeled
vehicles; the majority being soft-skinned. Yet, there were issues,
foremost of which was that the automotive industry of Italy was never
able to supply the number of vehicles that the RE (Regio Esercito –
Royal Italian Army) needed. While you will read within the pages of
these books how successful, well designed, and effective many of the
soft-skin vehicles of the Italian Armed Forces were, they just did not
have enough of them. The authors cite this as perhaps a very large part
of the reason the RE did not perform, at least against other modern
western militaries, as well as it may have. An army that was designed
around mobility was just not mobile enough, especially when compared to
its opponents and allies. For example,
Volume 1 outlines that Nicola Pignato (mentioned a number of times in
the book’s bibliography) estimated that Italy produced about 163,200
motor vehicles between 1940 and 1945. By comparison, Germany produced
130,000 Opel Blitz trucks, alone. The US: over 200,000 Studebaker,
382,350 Dodge WC, and 572.500 GMC trucks. The Italian’s civilian motor
vehicle ownership is also discussed as being not much better, and
neither it nor the colonies Italy had conquered could offer a solution.
In fact, the colonial conflicts had absorbed and degraded much of the
fleet Italy did have. There were also performance capability issues.
While Italian vehicles were of good quality, they lacked the range,
cross country ability and power of the opponent’s trucks previously
mentioned above. While the number of motor vehicles in Italy at the time
may have been low, the range was certainly diverse, and this was
reflected in the RE fleet. These books are a rich source of information
and pictures on that diverse range of military vehicles. Sold yet? How
are these volumes laid out? You will see by the tables of content, the
layout is standard enough: Volume 1 differs in having the authors’ notes
and Foreword, as well as the Overview and Explanatory Notes (which makes
up Section 1). Volume 2 on the other hand, contains the bibliography,
and appendices covering such topics as camouflage/markings,
manufacturers and even production under German control (’43 to ’45).
That said, the essential and best coverage in these volumes is the eight
(8) categories dedicated to the various vehicle types. So, buying
just one of either volume is not, in and of itself, problematic. Each
vehicle category is then laid out thusly: Development and Service
History, Technical Description, Variants and Specifications. There are
also several (almost entirely black and white) pictures accompanying
each vehicle type. In addition, there are also a handful of colour, or
colourised, photographs here and there. If, say, your interest was
confined to motorcycles, motor cars or light trucks, Volume 1 will
suffice. On the contrary, if your tastes were more based around the
medium to heavy trucks, trailers, tractors and or specialised vehicles,
then Volume 2 is for you. It’s easy for me to say, sitting here with
both books in hand, but if such a topic as Italian military vehicles in
general is something that interests you, do yourself a favour and get
both volumes. Let’s get
into the weeds a little, shall we? This, and the following paragraph
will detail the vehicle subjects covered in each category. If you’re
already sold on the books, then kudos to me, and read no further. If
you’re still wondering what bang you’re getting for your buck, then read
on: Section 1:
Overview and Explanatory Notes
·
Historical
Context.
·
Standardised
Military Trucks.
·
Engines and fuels.
·
Wheels and Tyres.
·
Right-Hand Drive.
·
Types of Bodywork.
·
Motocicletta
Volugrafo Aermoto
·
Motociclo Benelli
250 M37
·
Motociclo Benelli
500 VL Militare
·
Mototriciclo
Benelli 500 M36
·
Motociclo Bianchi
500 M
·
Motociclo Gilera
500 LTE
·
Motocarrozzetta
Gilera Marte 500
·
Motocarro Gilera
Mercurio
·
Motociclo Sertum
500 MCM
·
Motociclo Guzzi
500 Alce
·
Mototriciclo Guzzi
Trialce Section 3:
Motor Cars
·
Autovettura
Alfa Romeo 2500 C
·
Autovettura
Bianchi VM6 C
·
Autovettura Fiat
518 Coloniale
·
Autovetturetta
Fiat 508 M
·
Autovettura Fiat
508 C and 508 C Coloniale
·
Autovettura Fiat
508 CM (1100 Mimettica)
·
Autovetturetta
Fiat 500 Topolino
·
Autovettura Fiat
2800 CMC
·
Autovettura Lancia
Aprilia Coloniale
·
Autovettura Lancia
Artena Militare Section 4:
Light Trucks
·
Autocarretta OM
32, 35 and 36
·
Autocarro Leggero
SPA 25 C
·
Autocarro Leggero
Militare SPA 38 R and 36 R
·
Autocarro Leggero
Fiat 618 MC
·
Fiat 508 M
Camioncino and Furgoncino
·
Fiat 508 C and
1100 Camioncino and Furgoncino
·
Autocarro Leggero
SPA CL 39
·
Autocarro
Sahariano SPA AS 37
Volume 2:
Section 5: Medium and Heavy Trucks
·
Autocarro Medio
Alfa Romeo Tipo 500 and 500 RE
·
Autocarro
Unificato Medio Alfa Romeo Tipo 430 RE
·
Autocarro Medio
Bianchi Mediolanum
·
Autocarro
Unificato Medio Bianchi Miles
·
Autocarro Pesante
Militare Ceirano 50 CM
·
Autocarro Medio
Militare Ceirano 47 CM
·
Autocarro Pesante
Fiat 633 NM
·
Autocarro Militare
Pesante Unificato Fiat 634 NM
·
Autocarro Militare
Medio Unificato Fiat 626 NM and NLM
·
Autocarro Militare
Pesante Unificato Fiat 666 NM
·
Autocarro Militare
Pesante Unificato Fiat 665 NM
·
Autocarro Militare
Unificato Pesante Isotta Fraschini D80 NM
·
Autocarro Militare
Medio Isotta Fraschini D70 M
·
Autocarro Militare
Medio Isotta Fraschini D65
·
Autocarro Pesante
Lancia Ro NM and Ro BM
·
Autocarro Militare
Pesante Unificato Lancia 3Ro NM
·
Autocarro Militare
Medio Unificato Lancia Esaro
·
Autocarro Pesante
Militare OM 3 BOD
·
Autocarro Militare
Medio Unificato OM Taurus
·
Autocarro Fiat
Dovunque 33 and SPA Dovunque 35
·
Autocarro SPA
Dovunque 41
·
Autocarro Breda 51
and 52 Section 6:
Artillery Tractors
·
Trattore Pavesi P4
·
Trattore Pavesi
P4-100 Modello 26 and 30
·
Trattore Pesante
Breda Mod 32 and 33
·
Trattore Pesante
Breda Mod 40 and 41
·
Trattore Da
Montagna Fiat OCI 708 CM
·
Trattore Fiat OCI
40
·
Trattore Leggero
SPA TL 37
·
Trattore Medio SPA
TM 40
·
Trattore
Semicingolato Fiat 727
·
Trattore
Semicingolato Breda 61 Section 7:
Special Purpose Vehicles
·
Camionetta
Desertica SPA-Viberti AS 42
·
Camionetta
SPA-Viberti AS 43 Section 8:
Trailers
·
Tank Transport
Trailers
·
General Purpose
Cargo Trailers As an added
bonus, here is a list of the twelve (12) colour plates drawn by David
Bocquelet:
Volume 1: •
Fiat 508 CM. Italy, 1939. •
Autocaretta 35 light truck, Italian Alps, 1935. •
Fiat 618, East Africa, 1936. •
SPA 38R light truck, Eastern Front, 1941. •
SPA CL 39 light truck, Eastern Front, 1941. •
SPA AS 37 light truck, North Africa, 1942.
Volume 2: •
Fiat 634 NM heavy truck, Balkans, 1940. •
Lancia 3Ro heavy truck, Eastern Front, 1941. •
Fiat 626 NLM medium truck, Libya, 1942. •
SPA Dovunque 35 medium truck, Libya, 1942. •
Breda 32 heavy artillery tractor, Eastern Front, 1941. •
SPA TL37 light artillery tractor, Eastern Front, 1942.
Final thoughts: I have many. However, I’ll share a few
for an overall flavour. Negatives? I have none really. They’re more
“nitpicks”. For instance, I think an index would have been helpful.
Linked to this, the flow of each section (from vehicle to vehicle), is
such that you can miss the fact one vehicle has finished and you’re into
the next. Clearer delineation between each subject would be better,
especially flipping through pages to find a specific vehicle you wish to
view. Finally, there were no motorcycle colour plates. To me as a former
military motorcyclist, I’d have liked to have seen one. Like I said,
nitpicking. All small stuff, and by far eclipsed by the plethora of
pictures, and fascinating information covering all kinds of soft-skins.
On the
plus side, you will find endlessly fascinating and interesting subjects
in both volumes. In Volume One, there’s a photo comparison of a
Fiat 500 A Topolino, in German service, parked alongside the massive
Bussing-NAG Typ 650. Then you’ll see a Lancia Aprilia Coloniale
staff car in Ukraine, or an Autocarretta Ferroviaria Blindata modello
1942 converted to an armoured railway truck. Then on the very next page
there’s a SPA 25 C/10 ambulance in a wonderful, WWI style, camouflage.
In Volume 2 you’ll get much the same when discovering the huge range,
comparatively, of medium to heavy trucks. On one page there’s a
Fiat 626 in German service towing a Stuka across a field, then a large
section covering the Lancia 3Ro (including the mounting of artillery,
workshops, bowsers and wood fuel systems). These subjects are augmented
by the Dovunque 41s towing 88mm Flak guns, Fiat 727 and Breda 61
half-tracks (both licensed-built German vehicles) and certainly not to
be forgotten, the iconic Camionetta Desertica AS 42 and Camionetta AS
43.
Verdict? Highly
Recommended. |
Copyright: Glen Phelan - March 5, 2024 |