|
Please Support our Sponsors | ||||
Model Review
1/35 Kinetic Model Kits
RG-31 Mk 3 “US Army” Mine Protected APC
By Patrick Keenan - Editor
Basic Item Information
Item |
RG-31 Mk 3 “US Army” Mine Protected Armored Personnel Carrier |
Stock Number |
K61012 |
Manufacturer |
Kinetic Model Kits (Owned by former WarWheels.net Sponsor: Lucky Model) |
Scale |
1/35 |
Medium |
Styrene Plastic |
Kit Contents |
RG-31 Vehicle (211) Light tan plastic parts (27) Clear plastic parts (21) Black vinyl wheels and gun ports/covers (15) Brass photo-etched parts Bonus Figures (68) Light tan plastic parts Bonus Equipment Set |
Retail Price |
$45.99 (from Lucky Model) |
Reviewer |
Patrick Keenan - Editor |
Review Date |
February 12, 2013 |
Review Summary
Review Type |
First Look Review (Full Build to Folllow) |
Basic Positive Features |
Basic detail & shape of the vehicle appear to be replicated correctly; Kit subject matter welcome addition due to high visibility and use of real vehicle. |
Basic Negative Features |
UN vehicle option not able to be built as indicated. |
Recommendation |
Highly Recommended |
___________________________________________________________________________________________________
Photos
Model Sprue Photos Courtesy of Lucky Model
BONUS: 1/35 Master Box “US Soldiers Check Point Iraq” figures
BONUS: 1/35 J’s Work “Check Point Road Block Equipment Set”
Detailed Review
First
of all, to be up front with you all, Lucky Model (owner of Kinetic Model
Kits) WAS a sponsor of WarWheels.net at the time of this build.
With that
being said, we can start with the model review. Ever since the mid-2000’s the number of Mine
Resistant Ambush Protected (MRAP) vehicles fielded by the World’s
military organizations has increased dramatically. With the MRAP’s
higher visibility in the “real world”, the demand for model kits of
those vehicles has also increased. Unfortunately, until only
recently have we been provided with model kits of these vehicle types
and they still remain few and far between. However, good news is at hand in the form of this
model kit release of the 1/35 RG-31 Mark 3 “US Army” MRAP by Kinetic
Models. I really applaud the choice of the RG-31 as it is one of
the most noticeable and prolific MRAP vehicles used throughout the
world. But wait, there’s more! Kinetic’s first release batch
of RG-31 model kits also includes some FREE bonus goodies. These are in
the form of a set of four (4) 1/35 Master Box “US Soldiers Check Point
Iraq” figures and also 1/35 J’s Work “Check Point Road Block Equipment
Set”. PLEASE NOTE: I did NOT assess these bonus sets as a part of
this product review. However, I do want to notify you of what you
get with this model kit.
At this point of the review, you might be expecting a bit of background
information on the “real” RG-31 vehicle. However, you won’t be
getting any as I don’t generally provide background information
regarding the applicable real vehicles in my model kit reviews. In
my opinion, as a review reader most of the time that information
provided is VERY basic and/or a rehash of the summary provided with the
kit instructions anyway. However, if you are interested in some
basic information about and photographs of the RG-31 Nyala we already
have a lot of information and photos available about it here at
Warwheels.Net. Finally, this review is only an "In Box" or "first Look" review. I've done a rudimentary review of the model kit where I closely examined the kit parts, instruction sheet, packaging, etc. Thusly, I've provided comments of only my first impressions gathered while viewing the contents. I did NOT construct the kit yet, but a full build review is forthcoming. Kit Accuracy The accuracy of the model kit will be determined and
addressed here once the kit construction is completed. Stay tuned. Quality/Detail of Parts The quality of the casting of the plastic kit pieces
is good. There is very little flash present on the parts, and the
smallest pieces are also well cast, crisp and clean. Also, there
are a few mold punch-out holes present on some parts, but they mostly
appear in the hard to see/reach areas. The detail level of the individual plastic parts is
good, but not great as they seem a bit soft on detail. However, it
appears that the main details of the real vehicle are there and the
basic shapes look good as well. As for the detail level of the vinyl tires, and
photo-etched brass pieces; they are very good to excellent. The
tread pattern and detail of the tires is exceptionally done.
Another interesting point regarding the vinyl tires is that they are
provided by Kinetic separately; not attached to a “sprue”. The result is
tires that do NOT have any attachment points on them to remove. As we
all know, vinyl attachment parts are sometimes difficult to remove
without damaging the tires. I have to say that these vinyl tires
are some of the best I’ve seen in terms of detail AND ease of clean up.
As for the photo-etched parts, they are fairly basic. However,
they do add more fine detail only parts in that medium can replicate
easily; specifically the light guards being welcome.
Finally, although this next point is not directly related to the detail
of specific parts,
they do relate to the overall detail of the model. One of the vehicle
marking/painting options (“C”) Kinetic provides is of an RG-31 serving
with United Nations International Interim Force in Lebanon (UNIFIL).
The markings guide shows this vehicle as having no weapon turret or
window “gun ports”; a typical arrangement on the real UN vehicles.
However, the instructions never address this construction option by
omitting/changing parts. In addition, I have not found any
replacement parts in the kit to install windows without the gun ports or
to allow the sealing the turret aperture. Again as I mentioned before, I cannot yet provide a
final assessment of detail level of the kit due to the nature of a
“first look” review. However, stay tuned for the possibility of
changes and/or additional information being posted here as I begin
construction of the model kit. Decals, Markings &
Painting Information The decals Kinetic provides were designed by Bison
Decals and printed by Cartograph Decals and seem to be of very good
quality. The decals are printed in register in vibrant color and
look to be sufficiently thin enough to work well. However, until I
actually use them on the completed model, I’ll reserve full judgment
until then. Three marking/painting options are included with the
kit; Option “A” represents a Desert Tan-colored US vehicle from an
unknown unit fielded in Iraq (circa 2006); Option “B” represents another
Desert Tan US vehicle, this one fielded by an unknown US Marine Corps
unit; and Option “C” represents a white UNIFIL vehicle (Circa 2007). Finally, the painting guide for the vehicles’
exteriors, as well as the markings guide, are one in the same and
printed in black and white. The guide provides illustrations with
four views of each of the (2) US Vehicles and three views of the UN
vehicle. Painting information about specific details (vehicle
interior, lights, weapons, etc) is addressed throughout the instructions
based upon their construction sequence. Although the guide succeeds in effectively conveying
the proper placement of the decals/markings, it is more confusing as it
relates to the painting of the vehicles’ exteriors. For instance,
the guide indicates vehicle Options “A” and “B” should be painted in the
overall color “Stone”. However, if you check for “stone” in the
Paint Index at the front of the instruction sheet, it is not listed.
After a bit of head-scratching, I’ve come to the conclusion that the
Paint Index listing of “Base Color” equals the guide’s “Stone”.
Incidentally, modern US tan vehicles should be painted in the color CARC
686 Desert Tan (FS33446). Instructions/Packaging I believe that kit instructions are one of the most
underappreciated, yet most important aspects of hobby modeling. A
bad set of directions can cause unnecessary grief with an otherwise well
designed and engineered kit. On numerous occasions I have
struggled with a kit assembly only to figure out the solution by
accident. Afterwards, I’ll suddenly think, “That was easy once I got it.
Gee, why didn’t company X just show that better in the instructions?” Based upon observations made during my initial “in
box” review, Kinetic’s instructions appear to be very good. I
didn’t spot anything that looked wrong, omitted or overly complicated in
these instructions. Of course, that conclusion might change after
I’ve built the model kit, but that remains to be seen. I’ll update
this portion of the review (if need be) during/after my forthcoming full
build review write up. Anyway…the drawings themselves aren’t anything
special, but the design of the directions is utilitarian; they look to
be easy to follow and understand, especially considering the complexity
of some parts of the real RG-31. The diagrams for each individual
step are very specific as to what part goes where. When practical,
Kinetic includes directional arrows from one piece and go all the way to
another so as to leave no doubt where everything fits. Sometimes,
kit manufacturers include arrows, but they stray off in a general
direction and leave much guesswork as to where they go. Kinetic provides 20 steps in the instructions to
complete the RG-31 and there is generally enough room in each step to
facilitate ease of understanding. Most of the instruction steps are
clear and uncluttered and need minimal review. Some companies
knock down the total number of steps to a bare minimum but include way
too much information in each step to clearly understand what to do. Or
just as bad, they give a zillion sub-steps that further complicate
matters. Some instruction sheets are so confusing they make an
otherwise fun time into a true nightmare. However, these
instructions seem perfectly fine, but as I stated before, I’ll have to
reserve final judgment on the quality of instructions until I complete
the model kit build. Finally, Kinetic provides very good kit packaging and
“safety” by utilizing a box constructed of relatively sturdy cardboard.
They also follow the practice of bagging all sprues, decals and PE
separately. They’ve also included a small cardboard piece to further
protect the PE frets. One interesting aspect of their packaging is
the inclusion of re-sealable bags for all the parts. Although not
necessary, it is a nice touch if you’re like me and take joy in fondling
the model parts a bit before putting the kit on the “to do” shelf. Fit of Parts The fit of the model kit parts will be determined and
addressed here once the kit construction is completed. Stay tuned.
Although my review is of the “full build” variety, at this particular
time, I’ve not started the kit build. However, once I do start,
I’ll add content to this review as I complete portions of the kit.
Until the entire kit is built, the review will be similar to a “build
log” or “blog”. |
Conclusion So far based upon my “first look” assessment,
Kinetic has done a nice job on their RG-31 Mark 3 MRAP model kit.
Kinetic’s choice of releasing a kit of this well known and highly
utilized vehicle is a welcome addition for us wheeled fighting vehicle
modelers. Although the model kit appears a bit soft on the detail
level of individual parts, they are otherwise well cast: crisp and
cleanly molded. In addition, the basic detail and shape of
the vehicle appear to be replicated correctly. The only negative point I can make about the
model kit at this point is the instructions never address the specific
UNIFIL vehicle construction option steps nor provide any replacement
parts to model that version: windows without gun ports or to allow for
the omission of the weapon turret. Stay tuned for further developments
with this review as I start the construction of the model kit. Highly Recommended. Thanks to Kinetic Model Kits/Lucky Model for the review sample. |
Copyright: Patrick Keenan - February 2013 |